Elf Clan Social Network

The following is a major edit of the original blog, for good reason:  I happened to see a pre-release of the third episode of season 8 Doctor Who and thought it was the first episode... so was under incorrect assumption when I originally wrote the piece.

Since then I have seen episode 1 when it was released to the public, which has presented a different look at the series itself but didn't really change my opinion of episode 3 at all.  However it has changed my opinion of the potential of the new Doctor... so onward.

(See comments for running discussion of the series.)


After a rather long wait we have seen the new Doctor... and it was acceptable (even enjoyable).  I watched the show twice, two days in a row, the first time by myself and the second time with a friend.  I actually enjoyed it better the second time as I was able to pick up on a lot more of the subtle points.  Also probably because I wasn't expecting anything or surprised by anything, so I had more time to just sit and enjoy.

Deep Breath is exactly that... a moment to take a pause between the Matt Smith Doctor #11 and the Peter Capaldi Doctor #12. (No, there aren't 13 Doctors, as we were clearly told William Hurt was #8 1/2.  So there.  Okay... there were 13 Doctors.  But it's that timey wimey thing...) 

This first episode was an hour and 16 minutes long (or so), which resulted in mixed feelings.  On the one hand at times the show seemed to drag out and there were some unnecessary bits to it (such as the totally non-essential and lengthy carriage and horse ride to the... well... spoilers).  But on the other hand it gave them plenty of time to include all the detail and good parts they wanted to include without feeling rushed to do so. 


Unlike the previous doctors, Capaldi is a "mystery"... which means (for me at least) he wasn't instantly likeable.  I say this because I became a Doctor Who "fan" with the very first 2005 episode starring Christopher Eccleston, and I loved him as the Doctor (to this day he's still my favorite).  The same held true for David Tennant and Matt Smith; I enjoyed both of them with their first episode. 

Capaldi on the other hand presents a new Doctor.  On the one hand he had opportunity for some comic moments which reflected the performances of Tennant and Smith-- but somewhat unbelievably.  That's not unusual with a newly regenerated Doctor though; the character is meant to feel incoherent.  But Capaldi also brings a "darkness" to the role which is quite intentional.   It will be interesting to see how that continues in episode two.  (NOTE:  having seen the abysmal episode 3 already, I can state with confidence they do not maintain that darkness for very long, but that's covered in the second part of this blog).


"The Impossible Girl" returns in the form of Clara Oswald and Jenna Coleman is brilliant in the part.  A great deal of that is due to her quality acting... but also greatly due to excellent scripting of the character.  She is given some terrific lines in this episode.  Her "logic debate" with one of the featured fiends in the episode is flawless and quite believable-- and puts one in awe of Clara.  No wimp here, no brainless floozy, Clara Ozwald is fully capable of holding her own ground. 

One thing this entry presents (and which was pointed out in the post-review) is the echo Clara provides of the fans themselves.   How do we feel about this "new doctor"?  Is he the same Doctor with a new face... or has he been replaced and the Doctor we loved gone forever?   The hesitation and confusion of Clara very much mirrors that of the fans, who are wondering if Capaldi is going to present "as good" a Doctor as the previous three.  Are we going to like him?  Will he be believable in the role?  There have been Doctors in the past that the fans didn't like all that well (as Balpien testifies in a comment below).  What kind of Doctor will Capaldi prove to be? 

Clara's failure to immediately accept the regenerated Doctor lays those questions right out in front of us.   The resolution of the episode was excellent and over all, the entire episode well worth re-watching.   While the character of the "new Who" is not yet fleshed out well enough for us to readily embrace him, the series continues to hold true to itself through the first episode.  While Capaldi may be new, this is the same show.  So what will follow?


I've just had the enjoyment experience of watching a black-and-white pre-screening of the third episode of Doctor Who season 8.  I have not yet seen episode 2 as of this writing, and very much hate to write a negative review of a show which I have greatly enjoyed since its rebirth in 2005.  But the writers and directors really need to change lanes and quickly if the fanbase is going to accept Capaldi as our favorite Doctor.  Episode 3 is simply horrid.

Note: there will be no spoilers in this review, so no need to worry.  I plan to discuss the show and characters, not the plot.  I'm also going to keep this relatively short, so you may breathe more easily.


Does that sound at all like The Doctor?  Agreed, he has been all of these things at varied times in the past, but not all of them at once and not all the way through every scene of the episode.  Capaldi seemed to have great potential in this role-- if he were playing a more "serious" Doctor who knew something about what he was doing as was the case with episode 1.  Such might even be a refreshing difference from the past three Doctors.  Although I loved the actors and their roles, I'm up for something a little new-- a Doctor a bit more dark, a touch more alien, a bit more commanding and capable.  In such role Capaldi would probably shine.

But in the role of a clown who bickers, takes no delight in his surroundings, is highly incompetent and cobbles around like Inspector Clouseau... the new actor's potential is lost in episode 3 and the character winds up being immensely unlikeable.


The saving grace of the show is Clara, played by Jenna Coleman.  After the great charm of Rose Tyler, Amy Pond and River Song, Clara "The Impossible Girl" brings equal brightness to the show.  Like the companions mentioned, Clara is no wimp constantly falling on the Doctor to save the day.  She is capable, competent, determined and is excellent in this role.  She could probably carry a show of her own; her acting abilities and screen presence takes center stage.  As such she is thus far the saving grace of this show, frankly the only part of the first episode 3 found worth watching.

Episode 1 was quite acceptable-- the typical mixed feelings of a regeneration, new Doctor and confusion that becomes somewhat resolved by the end of the episode.  But episode 3 totally reverses and spoils the entire concept and accomplishment of the first episode and makes us wonder "What were they thinking when they wrote this... nay... when they directed and released it?"  If this show is going to succeed, if they're going to maintain their American fanbase (or even the British one for that matter), they're going to need to change directions and make the Doctor a bit more mature, quite a bit more competent, a bit wiser.  That's what we want, that's what the fans are expecting, and that's what they will demand.  Any more of the current schlock and folks will likely be turning their sets to reruns of Firefly.


* Actually, I found Eccleston's portrayal very enjoyable and was most disappointed he left after only one season.  As much as I enjoyed Tennant's and Smith's Doctors... for me Eccleston created "the perfect Doctor"... that mixture of sheer joy of life mixed with repressed grief.  Not old, not young, capable of both humor and judgment, the leather-jacket Doctor was just serious enough and happy enough to make the character totally believable... and is what made me a fan of the show.  Both Tennant and Smith carried that on admirably and created their roles very well, but everyone has their "favorite Doctor", yes?  And their Favorite "Who Girl".  Rose.  Ah Rose.  How the great have fallen (seriously... a hooker?).  And now I hear that Clara is leaving the show just as we were starting to really warm up to her character.  Tch. 

At least we had River Song, who I didn't like at first but then who captivated me both with her acting prowess and fascinating character development.  And with Amy-- the Girl Who Waited... and Rory-- the loyal Last Centurion (or alternately... the guy who died, a lot...), What a season!

Views: 341

Comment by Balpien Hammerer on August 18, 2014 at 4:43pm


Does that sound at all like The Doctor?"

Yes, Colin Baker. I did not like that Doctor to the point I just stopped watching the series until he was done.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 18, 2014 at 4:48pm

You're right Balpien.  As I wrote this I actually thought, "Wait... I'm not well acquainted with the pre-2005 Doctor Who."  And I'd heard rumors about prior actors- with- attitude (didn't know which ones).  Seems Doctor Who's greatest enemy has returned-- and it is himself.

Comment by Ferrator Montoya on August 18, 2014 at 4:55pm

I have yet to see the new Doctor, so no comment, I have no basis or experience.

Seems Doctor Who's greatest enemy has returned-- and it is himself.

Supposed last survivor of Gallifrey? Hundreds of years of solitary existence regarding his own? I don't know about you but all that would get my Angst motor going.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 18, 2014 at 5:03pm

Not only that, but we have no idea how many times he's loved and lost, married and widowed, etc.  But with Smith's leaving they set the stage for a new kind of Doctor, one who would love life and "never forget anything".  Then they bring in this character. 

I know each new Doctor has a different personality from the previous-- which brings lots of potential to the show.  But one doesn't go from the Matt Smith Doctor to "incompetent dufus"... or at least hopefully not.

In earnest though, being in the U.S. I've only seen the pre-release of the 3rd episode (haven't seen the first two of series 8 yet) so I may be wrongly judging him.  But since 2005's first rebirth I've never seen a "bad" episode of Doctor Who... until now. 

Brrrrrr.  It could change all of British society.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 18, 2014 at 5:06pm

Side note:  I added a tribute end-piece to the main blog.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 24, 2014 at 6:28am

Having now seen the first episode of the new Doctor Who, I think there are a couple of things involved here:

1) They really don't have the new character fleshed out yet.  They don't seem to know which direction he's going-- which is somewhat normal for a regeneration.

2) The actor is trying too hard.  He's "over the top" too much.  That is also somewhat normal for a regeneration.  (Remember Matt Smith and the fish fingers and custard episode?)

Hopefully they'll have this worked out by episode 4 or 5 because otherwise this will become fairly tiresome.  Episode 1 was far better than episode 3, and I even enjoyed watching it (episode 3 was the pits).  We'll see on episode 2 how they do on the bridge between the two.  Episodes 4 and 5 will be the "teller".

I remember on Star Trek Next Generation, the first six episodes were terrible.  But after that they had their stride and it was pretty enjoyable.

Comment by Ferrator Montoya on August 24, 2014 at 8:16am

I do not see any of this. Ok, I DO see a confused SOB [after about a dozen regenerations who wouldn't be?] individual trying to remember/come to grips with who he is.

And as to Clara saving the day, she DID have a bit of help if I was watching the same episode.

Personally, I like the new Doctor and I thought the premier was well done.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 24, 2014 at 11:41am

My negative review was on a pre-release of episode 3.  Wait until you see it.  Ugh.

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 26, 2014 at 9:10pm

Major blog edit notice:   having just seen episode 1 this weekend, I added a pre-section to the original post about episode 3.  Perhaps this gives the blog a bit more "balanced" viewpoint... but a great deal of my overall take on the show will depend heavily on episodes 2 (to be released this Saturday) and 4 (which will come 2 weeks later).  Until then, the above self-debate regarding the quality of the show perhaps at least will echo the general feelings of the fans when they see episode 3 a little less than two weeks from now.   Or not.  After all, it's Doctor Who.  They can get away with almost anything.  (It is rumored they keep several plastic sharks* on the set depending on the size they have to jump each episode.  Not that the series declines afterward... which is the point being made.)

* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark

Comment by Wayfinder Wishbringer on August 31, 2014 at 6:25pm


It will be my best effort in these comments to not include spoilers... but just in case I slip it may be best to watch the episode before reading my comments on it.

This is probably one of the top Doctor Who episodes I've seen.  Not only do we see a very new Doctor, we see a side to Daleks never before seen... and then beyond.  The multiple twist of this episode-- both in the presentation of the new Doctor and the Daleks-- sends out the message that this is indeed a new Doctor, not just a replay of the old characters.

Into the Dalek caused mixed emotions:

* I came to like the Doctor even more, dislike him even more, and identify with him even more.  Here we see a Doctor that is so competent it's scary.  We see a side of his personality that we've not seen before (or at least, had only caught a glimpse of before).   We also get an almost definite answer to the mystery question of Episode 1 (which I shan't mention)... as this expanded insight into the Doctor leaves little doubt as to the answer to that question.  (If you don't know what I'm talking about... well, watch Episode 1: Deep Breath).

* For the first time I disliked Claire just a little bit.  Still a wonderful person, but very... cocky and just a tad arrogant.  It makes it even more irritating in that she's totally right in everything.  Nothing is so irritating as someone who thinks they know it all than when they actually do.   Other than that... I still like Jenna in the part.  She's performs the role well.  It's just that at this point, the writers are making the character pretty flawless and pretty transparent ie:  not much mystery any more.  She's not a romantic interest any more, her main task as "The Impossible Girl" was completed in the Matt Smith series, and we are left with a cute and pretty "Donna Noble"-- a character I didn't much like in the first place.  As of this episode it makes Jenna leaving the show more understandable; it appears they've done as much with her as they can do within the current context.   To do any more they'd have to present her in a completely new light, with a total twist on her existence.  That's not likely to happen.  Exit thus, stage left.

* One has to wonder what the Doctor has against soldiers... since he himself has been one.  Maybe that's precisely what he doesn't like about them.

That's about it for this episode.  Splendid writing, great acting, great presentation... and an exact representation of The Doctor that fans were hoping to see:  one not quite so humorous, frivolous or "human"... or maybe too human.  We see a doctor here that is dark, brooding, highly efficient, and at odds with himself.  If they keep that up, we can look forward to a fairly interesting season.

It makes me almost sorry I've already seen the schlock that comprises Episode 3 and goes against every benefit of Episode 2.  Hopefully Episode 4 saves the series from such divergence into absurdity and allows the show to climb back on its feet from a rather hideous episodic fall.   But Into the Dalek was Doctor Who at its finest.


You need to be a member of Elf Clan Social Network to add comments!

Join Elf Clan Social Network

© 2017   Created by Wayfinder Wishbringer.   Powered by

Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service